I've been looking for a fic I stumbled across a while back, and I've had no luck seeing as I don't remember the author, or the title...or where I found it. But I've seen the requests put in here, and I see what you people can do, so I have complete faith!
Here's what I remember:
John was on a hunt, so Dean and Sam were left alone in some small town. Sam went out with some friends..to a party, or something. Dean went to find him (I don't remember why), and found him being arrested. Sam claims that the boys he was with told him that it was his parents' house, and they were going to get drinks, but the cops say the other boys claimed Sam was their ringleader. The cops talked Dean into having sex with them in exchange for letting Sam go. They locked Sam in the car with them while they raped Dean, and they talked about keeping Dean. They let the boys go, but they couldn't leave town, and they were going to come back for Dean and take him to "the strip" to become a prostitute for them.
Sam is scared to get help because he knows his father will be mad at him for getting Dean into this mess, but he knows he needs to call John, seeing as the cops have them trapped in town and they can't get out. They can't reach John, so they call Bobby and he tries to get them out. I remember that Dean makes Sam go to school as normal, because he wants Sam out of harm's way..
If anyone knows what I'm talking about, even if it's a deleted fic, I'll be forever grateful!
(Mods, I hope I did all this right..if I didn't, I'll be sure to fix it!)
*Edit: found! link in comments.